Memorandum § VII · GX 306 § 4(A)

The Arc

WSA’s Charter requires it “to support, at all times,” the goals of the United Nations. This page follows that mandate through the record, from the launch at UN Geneva in 2006 to the UN lobby in 2019, and sets it against the Government’s claim of a ten-year void.

GX 306 · Section II, Article 4(A)

“At all times”

The Government put WSA’s Charter in evidence as its own exhibit. The Charter does not make UN work optional or occasional. It makes it the organization’s standing purpose.

The mandate, and the “void”

GX 306 § II, Art. 4(A) · Tr. 1041 · Tr. 1087 · ECF 146 at 13–14
What the Government told the jury and the court
  • Closing · Tr. 1041“[N]o evidence of any interaction” between WSA and the UN from 2008 to 2018.
  • Rebuttal · Tr. 1087“[T]he closest he got to the UN was having an apartment office across the street.”
  • 2025 · ECF 146 at 13–14No “UN-associated work” before April 2019.
What the Government’s own exhibit says WSA exists to do
  • GX 306 · Section II, Article 4(A)“The goal of the WSA is to involve itself to support, at all times, one or more of the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and, since September 25, 2015 to support, at all times, one or more of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).”
  • GX 306 · Preamble (K)WSA “has concluded a partnership with the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UNDESA), through the UN-NGO-IRENE.”
The motion says that under this mandate “there is no category of WSA activity that is not UN-mandated activity.” (Memorandum § VII) The record below is how the mandate played out, year by year.
Charter page 9, Section II, Article 4(A) highlighted: to support, at all times, the United Nations’ development goals.GX 306 at 9 · Article 4(A)
Tap an image to see it full size.
DX 11 · DX 2 · DX 6 · GX 306 · GX 2801 · PX 32–34

The arc, 2006 to 2019

Every stop is a trial exhibit, a transcript page or a docket filing. Nothing here comes from outside the court record.

Founding, 2006–2008

  1. July 5, 2006 · DX 11Launched at UN Geneva

    The UN’s own ECOSOC record book documents the launch of the World Sports Alliance at UN Geneva, co-hosted by UN‑NGO‑IRENE. A UN official who took part wrote that he looked forward to WSA’s work “to propel the development goals of United Nations even further.” (DX 11 at 214; PX 888)

  2. September 11–14, 2006 · DX 2 at 2A joint workshop in New York

    The Rabat Declaration recalls “the Expert Workshop organized by the United Nations Non-Governmental Organizations Section and WSA, held in New York.”

  3. January 26, 2007 · ECF 135 at 116–18The MOU with UN‑NGO‑IRENE

    Signed by the Chief of the NGO Section, UN DESA. It names WSA as a partner (id. at 126–27) and stays in force until terminated on two months’ written notice. No termination notice is in the record.

  4. May 29, 2007 · DX 2The Rabat Declaration

    UN document E/2007/NGO/1. Ministers of three states “welcome the admission” of their countries “to membership of the intergovernmental organization WSA.” The Charter names it WSA’s “constitutive Act.” (GX 306 § 1(A))

  5. July 2007 · GX 2801; Tr. 871–72Geneva, with the Secretary-General

    The Government’s own exhibit shows the UN Secretary-General holding the Rabat Declaration in front of the WSA emblem. Saint Clair identified him at trial without objection. See the photograph.

  6. October 15, 2008 · GX 306The Charter

    WSA’s Charter fixes its goal: “to support, at all times, one or more of the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals.” (§ II, Art. 4(A))

The member states, 2008–2016

  1. 2008 onward · DX 6; Tr. 824Thirty-one states accede

    Each state’s instrument pledges “to unconditionally support World Sports Alliance in furtherance of the UN 2005 Millennium Development Goals.” Accessions in the exhibit run into 2013. Received in evidence without a limiting instruction.

  2. December 2015 · GX 306The Charter is revised for the new UN goals

    The mandate carries over: “since September 25, 2015 to support, at all times, one or more of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals.” (§ II, Art. 4(A))

  3. November 1, 2016 · ASC 102Saint Clair joins as Treasurer

    His appointment letter lists UN DESA NGO Section and UN‑NGO‑IRENE among WSA’s partners. (ECF 171-1 at 131)

Saint Clair’s tenure, 2017–2019

  1. Between 2015 and 2017 · Tr. 787–88“I met him at the United Nations in New York”

    A defense witness told the jury where he met Saint Clair: “I met him at the United Nations in New York.” Asked by the court when, he answered “sometime between 2015 and 2017.” He added that UNGSII “tried to promote the good work of the WSA.”

  2. After April 30, 2017 · Tr. 969–70The UN closes its sport office

    The UN Office on Sport for Development and Peace closed, and WSA moved to “take over.”

  3. July 24, 2017 · ECF 150-1 at 21–24The UNGSII joint venture

    A written agreement with the institute run by the UN Director-General’s Senior Advisor, for projects benefiting the UN Geneva campus.

  4. August 2017 · ECF 135 at 33, 52, 80Meeting the Director-General

    Saint Clair met UN Director-General Michael Møller.

  5. January 2018 · ECF 135 at 52 ¶¶ 27–28Davos

    Schatz swore that Saint Clair deepened WSA’s relationship with Director-General Møller there, and that he introduced Saint Clair to former Secretary-General Kofi Annan.

  6. September 2017 to June 2018 · Tr. 441–42, 511–12Speaking inside UN headquarters

    On direct, the Government’s insider witness said he was not aware of Saint Clair meeting or communicating with anyone who worked for the UN: “Not to my knowledge, no.” On cross he agreed he went inside the United Nations with Saint Clair for a conference on the role of women in business and politics in India: “we sat in on that conference.” Asked whether Saint Clair spoke, he said, “I believe he had a moment,” and agreed he took pictures of the speech. The witness worked at WSA from September 2017 to June 2018 (Tr. 363–64). Saint Clair dates the conference to March 2018.

  7. Early 2018 · Tr. 574–75Planning a fundraiser at UN headquarters

    On the Government’s own direct examination, a Government witness testified that Saint Clair “asked me to accompany him to the U.N.” to “look at space for potential event to hold there,” “some sort of fundraiser, dinners.” They met there, and a UN staff member showed them the space. Asked what she observed of Saint Clair with the UN staff, she said: “It looks just normal to me,” and “I didn’t notice anything abnormal in terms of the behavior.” Saint Clair dates the visit to January 2018.

  8. September 2018 · GX 2705–2706; Tr. 925–27The UN’s letter, and what followed

    The UN’s legal office objected to WSA’s emblem and website. WSA answered in eight days and offered to meet. Saint Clair testified there was no reply.

  9. January 2019 · DX 22; Tr. 858–60Davos again

    With Director-General Møller at the SDG programming.

  10. March 2019 · PX 1; ECF 150-1 at 5–6President

    Saint Clair is promoted to President of WSA.

  11. April 4, 2019 · DX 17, DX 19; PX 32–34; Tr. 926Inside the UN lobby

    The UN Mine Action Service names WSA a “Champion” of its Safe Ground campaign, gives Saint Clair an award, installs WSA’s turf in the visitors’ lobby of UN headquarters, and posts its own sign crediting “collaborative partnerships with the World Sports Alliance.”

  12. September 25–27, 2019 · Tr. 861–63The Vatican

    Saint Clair attends the conference on “the Common Good in the Digital Age” and meets Pope Francis. The search of WSA’s offices is executed while he is there.

Exhibit B: the arc of WSA and UN engagement from 2006 to 2019.Exhibit B · the unbroken arc, 2006–2019
Demonstrative chart filed with the motion. It organizes record evidence; it is not itself evidence. Tap to enlarge.

If WSA is “to support, at all times,” the United Nations’ goals, was Saint Clair arrested and sent to prison for merely doing his job?

NextThe witnesses →§ VIII · The Government's own witnesses