Before there was an indictment, Saint Clair voluntarily gave the Government his phone, the names of his UN contacts and his plans to move to Arizona. Crucially, Saint Clair gave the prosecutor the password to his cloud drive, granting access to his entire digital universe. Thus, the motion says, there is nothing the Government can say it did not know before misrepresenting any of the facts. All of it is in the prosecutor’s own notes. Three weeks later, at the very first proceeding in the case, the court was told the opposite. The motion says this is the pattern of the entire case: the Government arguing against its own evidence.
ECF 150-1 at 32 · page one
ECF 150-1 at 35 · “Shd talk to Mr Schatz”
ECF 150-1 at 37 · personal details blacked outHighlighting was added when the notes were filed.
The prosecutor wrote a third UN name that day, and wrote it twice: Kofi Annan, the seventh Secretary-General of the United Nations. On page one, directly beneath Møller and Schatz: “Kofi Annan’s idea. Sports theme.” (ECF 150-1 at 32) On page four, under her own instruction “Shd talk to Mr Schatz”: “hired by Kofi Annan to help w/ sustainability initiative.” (ECF 150-1 at 35) On page two she recorded how WSA came to exist: “Intergovernmental Org. = 3 govs come together to sign treaty: Morocco, Niger, DR. 33 member states.” (ECF 150-1 at 33)
ECF 150-1 at 32 · “Kofi Annan’s idea. Sports theme.”
ECF 150-1 at 35 · “hired by Kofi Annan”
ECF 150-1 at 33 · “3 govs come together to sign treaty”Excerpts from the filed notes. Yellow highlighting on these three excerpts was added by this site.
Each of those lines matches a document the jury later received. The “sports theme” is a resolution of the UN General Assembly, “Sport as a means to promote education, health, development and peace,” adopted November 3, 2005. It asks the Secretary-General to “expand and strengthen United Nations partnerships with Governments, sport-related organizations and the private sector.” (DX 6 at 12–13) Kofi Annan was Secretary-General from 1997 to 2006. WSA’s membership form says the organization “draws its mandate from” the first resolution of that name, Resolution 58/5. (DX 6 at 16) The three governments are the ones that signed the Rabat Declaration, and the same exhibit carries the official portrait of the King of Morocco. (DX 2; DX 6 at 7)
Roland Schatz has since sworn to both points in her notes: that Annan and former Swiss President Adolf Ogi “were both instrumental in the formation of the World Sports Alliance” (ECF 135 at 50 ¶ 13), and that he introduced Saint Clair to Annan in person at Davos in January 2018 (ECF 135 at 52 ¶ 28). See the photograph.
DX 6 at 12 · General Assembly resolution 60/9 · highlighting added
DX 6 at 7 · “His Majesty King Mohammed VI”DX 6 was received in evidence without a limiting instruction. (Tr. 824) Tap a page to read it full size.
This was the first proceeding in the case, before the first judge to hear it. The motion alleges that what the Government told the court there was contradicted by its own evidence: the prosecutor’s notes and the check its agents had seized. In the motion’s words, “Once that misrepresentation was made, the pattern did not vary.”
- Oct. 23, 2019 · to the magistrate judge“He indicated that he lived in New York, that he intended to continue to live in New York.” (ECF 34 at 28)
- Same hearing“At no point did he disclose this residence in Scottsdale, Arizona.” (ECF 34 at 28)
- Nov. 13, 2019 · to the district judgeThe same flight-risk narrative, continued. (ECF 10 at 8)
- The prosecutor’s notes, weeks earlier“plans to move to AZ next week”; “plans to live in Scottsdale, AZ”; a “$50K check.” (ECF 150-1 at 37–39)
- The seized checkThe $50,000 relocation check, dated September 17 and seized September 26, bore the Scottsdale address. (PX 08; ECF 150-1 at 29–30)
- The search-warrant affidavitWSA “was required to vacate” its New York premises by September 30, 2019. (ECF 30-1; ECF 30-3 at 2)
- ECF 146 at 17He “had disclosed … that he intended to move to Arizona” but “had not disclosed that he had a residence there as of July 2019.”
- UnswornNo declaration, affidavit or testimony from any person supports that reading: not from the prosecutor, and not from the Government’s only affiant, whose affidavit does not address it. (ECF 146-1)
- The law“[A]n attorney’s unsworn statements in a brief are not evidence.” (Kulhawik v. Holder, 571 F.3d 296, 298 (2d Cir. 2009))
- The motion’s conclusionThe bail statement “stands unrebutted as a matter of law — and it is how this case began: the first proceeding, the first judicial officer, … before any trial strategy existed.”
PX 08 · ECF 150-1 at 30 · the seized checkAddresses, phone numbers, emails, account numbers and signatures are blacked out. Tap a page to read it full size.
At some point after the trial, the former prosecutor whose conduct the motion challenges became a partner at the law firm where the presiding judge had been a partner for many years before he took the bench. In September 2025, while the § 2255 motion was pending, Saint Clair brought this to the court’s attention. The judge answered in a footnote to the ruling. Saint Clair did not raise the point in his appeal.
- The fact · ECF 159 at 1The former prosecutor, “whose conduct is at issue in Ground Four,” had joined the firm as a partner in its white-collar defense practice. The firm’s announcement was attached as Exhibit A.
- What he did not claim · ECF 159 at 2Because the judge left the firm more than twenty years ago, “Petitioner does not allege a statutory conflict of interest under 28 U.S.C. § 455.”
- What he did say · ECF 159 at 2The development “underscores the appearance of partiality.” He cited Offutt v. United States, 348 U.S. 11, 14 (1954): “justice must satisfy the appearance of justice.”
- What he asked for · ECF 159 at 2That the court take judicial notice of the fact (Fed. R. Evid. 201) and consider it with the motion.
- How the ruling describes it · ECF 206 at 22One of the “unauthorized submissions”: a notice “stating that a prosecutor in the case against him had joined the firm in which the undersigned had been a partner until October 31, 2003.”
- The footnote · ECF 206 at 22 n.6“While the undersigned cannot discount the possibility that he has exchanged pleasantries with the individual at a public event, he had no conversations regarding her decision to join the law firm or the substance of this case. The undersigned left the particular law firm over twenty-two years ago.”
- On appealThe application for a certificate of appealability (2d Cir. No. 26-2228, Dkt. 10) does not raise this point. It is set out here because it is part of the record.