United States v. Saint ClairNo. 19 Cr. 790 · Federal court, New York

The Saint Clair CaseA motion to vacate a wire-fraud conviction for fraud upon the court

In 2022 a federal jury convicted Asa Saint Clair of wire fraud. In his motion to vacate that conviction, he alleges the Government won it by telling the court and the jury things its own notes, witnesses and exhibits contradict, at every stage of the case, and never correcting them.

This site sets each of those statements beside the Government’s own record. Every line is cited, so you can check it yourself.

The allegations are Saint Clair’s, as stated in his court filings. The court denied the motion on July 23, 2026. His appeal is pending in the Second Circuit.

Watch: the case in three minutes, from the record.AI narration. Every statement on screen is cited.

The motion’s central claim

Not one mistake: a pattern, from the first hearing to the ruling

The motion alleges the same thing happened at every stage. The Government told the court something its own record contradicted, built on it, and never took it back. In the motion’s words: “The scheme began at the bail hearing with a misrepresentation contradicted by the prosecutor’s own notes and a seized check. It continued through pre-trial …; through trial …; and post-conviction.”

  1. October 2019The bail hearing“At no point did he disclose this residence in Scottsdale, Arizona.” The prosecutor’s own notes said he had.ECF 34 at 28
  2. 2021–2022Before trialThree timelines for the coin in one filing, and a white paper re-dated to 2020.ECF 73; ECF 73-1
  3. March 2022At trial“No partnership,” an altered letter, and “he tried to hide it.”Tr. 29, 959–66, 1053
  4. March 2022Closing argumentsStatements its own witnesses and exhibits contradict, several in rebuttal, the Government’s final word.Tr. 1033–94
  5. 2025After convictionOne admission: no contract says “revenue positive.” Nothing else corrected.ECF 146 at 21
  6. July 2026The rulingThe motion called “recycle[d]”; the “apartment across the street” called “a figure of speech.”ECF 206 at 25–26
Closing arguments · March 2022

The last words the jury heard

A closing argument is meant to sum up the evidence. Here is what the Government told the jury in closing, set beside its own exhibits and witnesses. Several of these came in rebuttal, the Government’s final word, after the defense had spoken and could not answer.

“The misconduct culminated in a rhetorical ambush during rebuttal, where the Government introduced the ‘revenue positive’ theory for the first time … timed to prevent defense rebuttal.”The motion’s claim · ECF 150 at 72
What the Government told the juryWhat its own record shows
What the ruling said about it

The judge called the “apartment office across the street” line “a figure of speech in the government’s closing argument that caused him no prejudice.” (ECF 206 at 25)

After the verdict

Confronted with the record, the Government corrected nothing

In the motion’s words: “When confronted with this record in § 2255 briefing, the Government corrected nothing. It conceded what it could not deny, recast what it could not concede, and remained silent on the rest.” Then the court ruled. Read the ruling against the record, and decide for yourself.

  1. July 2025 · the Government’s sworn answer

    The “sham affidavit”

    The Government answered the motion with one sworn document: an affidavit from Saint Clair’s own trial lawyer. At trial, that lawyer told the jury that Saint Clair “didn’t lie about the UN relationship” and that the coin “launched.” In the affidavit he swore the opposite: that Saint Clair had made an “admission that the WSA had no relationship with the UN,” and that investors thought they were buying “a cryptocurrency that did not exist.” The motion calls it a “Sham Affidavit.” The Government relied on it, and so did the ruling, which quotes it again and again.

    ECF 146-1 ¶¶ 26, 66 · Tr. 1070, 1079 · ECF 150 at 12–17 · ECF 206 at 5–6, 12–16
  2. 2025 · the Government’s answer

    One admission

    The Government conceded that Saint Clair’s contracts “did not use the term ‘revenue positive,’” the phrase it gave the jury in its final minutes, along with “he lied about it.” Nothing else was corrected.

    ECF 146 at 21 · Tr. 1094
  3. 2026 · the ruling

    “Befuddled”

    The jury was never given a definition of “affiliate.” The legal definition requires control: one that “controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with” another. The UN did not control WSA. The ruling said giving the jury that definition “likely would have befuddled the jury.”

    ECF 206 at 18 · 17 C.F.R. § 230.405 · Tr. 959, 1000
  4. 2026 · the ruling

    “Recycle[d]”

    The ruling disposed of the fraud-upon-the-court motion by saying Saint Clair “largely recycles arguments” already rejected. The appeal notes the Government had not opposed that motion, and says the ruling never applied the fraud-upon-the-court test to the pattern the motion laid out.

    ECF 206 at 26 · 2d Cir. Dkt. 10 at 5–6
  5. September 2025 · the appearance of justice

    The prosecutor’s new firm

    At some point after the trial, the former prosecutor whose conduct the motion challenges became a partner at the law firm where the judge had been a partner for many years. Saint Clair asked the court to take judicial notice of the fact, citing the rule that “justice must satisfy the appearance of justice.” The judge answered in a footnote.

    ECF 159 at 1–2 · ECF 206 at 22 n.6
Every statement

What the Government claimed, and what its own record shows

All the statements the motion challenges, in the order it sets them out, from the bail hearing to the Government’s 2025 brief. Tap a row to see the documents.

What the Government claimedWhat the Government’s own record shows
World Sports Alliance, Intergovernmental Organization
Asa Saint Clair shaking hands with Pope Francis at the Vatican, a cardinal smiling behind them.Saint Clair with Pope Francis at the Vatican, September 27, 2019, the day after the search
Roland Schatz’s United Nations grounds pass, reading United Nations, Director-General, Roland Schatz, 31 Dec 2015.The UN pass of Roland Schatz, Sr. Advisor to the Director-General, who encouraged him to cooperate · ECF 135 at 173

“The UN told me to cooperate”Rome, September 26, 2019, the day before he met Pope Francis at the Vatican

The prosecutor’s handwritten notes of the September 26, 2019 call: Call with Asa Saint Clair. Meeting with Pope tomorrow. Highlighted: talked to UN, told me to cooperate. Work with government, will answer questions. Does not have a lawyer.The prosecutor’s own notes of his call from Rome, September 26, 2019 · ECF 150-1 at 32 · highlighting added when filed

Confirmed under oath by Roland Schatz, Sr. Advisor to UN Director-General Michael Møller: “I encouraged Mr. Saint Clair to fully cooperate with this action.” ECF 135 at 58 ¶ 67

On September 26, 2019, when agents searched the offices of the World Sports Alliance (WSA) in connection with a matter pre-dating his tenure, Asa Saint Clair, the organization’s president, was inside the Vatican. By his account he was meeting Pope Francis and senior Vatican officials about work on the very cryptocurrency the Government would later call a fraud (Tr. 669; Saint Clair Decl. ¶¶ 2–3). He called the prosecutor from Rome that same day, on the advice of United Nations officials who, in his words recorded by the prosecutor, “told [me] to cooperate” (ECF 150-1 at 32). On September 30, back from Rome, he walked into the U.S. Attorney’s Office voluntarily and without a lawyer. He answered questions, let agents forensically search his phone, gave the prosecutor the password to his cloud drive, and then left. The Government’s own agent agreed he was “absolutely” free to go (Tr. 648–49, 669–70). He disclosed his UN contacts, his cryptocurrency, his pay arrangements, his move to Arizona and his work in Madagascar. The Government arrested him in Los Angeles on October 10, 2019, and, the motion says, “investigated none of the leads he had handed it.”

The motion further asserts that Saint Clair’s cooperation was analyzed for what to conceal, alter and omit, and was then weaponized with affirmative arguments opposite to what the evidence shows. The motion claims the Government created a “false factual universe” based upon Saint Clair’s cooperation (Memorandum §§ IV, XIII).

How it started

The Rosetta Stone, and the bail hearing

The motion calls the prosecutor’s handwritten notes of those interviews “the Rosetta Stone of this motion” (PX 09; ECF 150-1 at 31–40). They were written in real time, in her own hand, and they record two things at once: what he disclosed, and the fact that the Government knew it. “A prosecutor cannot innocently tell a court the opposite of what she herself wrote down.”

The first misrepresentation

ECF 34 at 28 · ECF 150-1 at 29–30, 37, 39
Oct. 23, 2019 · what the court was told
  • Bail hearing · ECF 34 at 28“At no point did he disclose this residence in Scottsdale, Arizona.”
Weeks earlier · what the prosecutor wrote
  • Her notes · ECF 150-1 at 37, 39“plans to move to AZ next week”; “plans to live in Scottsdale, AZ.”
  • The seized check · ECF 150-1 at 29–30A $50,000 relocation check bearing the Scottsdale address.
“Once that misrepresentation was made, the pattern did not vary.”
The prosecutor’s notes, highlighted: plans to move to AZ next week; plans to live in Scottsdale, AZ.ECF 150-1 at 37 · personal details blacked out
Tap an image to see it full size.
Relief requested

What the motion asks the court to do

  1. Vacate the judgment of conviction as procured by fraud upon the court.
  2. Hold an evidentiary hearing on the fraud-upon-the-court allegations.
  3. Dismiss the indictment with prejudice.
  4. Grant such further relief as the court deems just and proper, including any remedial orders necessary to restore the integrity of the judicial process.
Where it stands

The court denied the motion on July 23, 2026 (ECF 206 at 26). Saint Clair filed a notice of appeal with the Second Circuit on August 6, 2026, alleging that the judge failed to engage with the legal arguments presented. His application for a certificate of appealability followed on September 4, 2026 (No. 26-2228). The appeal is pending. Read the ruling.

NextWhat they knew →§§ IV–V · The Government's knowledge, and the bail hearing